2025-06-25 11:18 UTC
Replies (3)
-
@Asimech@mastodon.social 2025-06-25 11:32
@mark@mastodon.fixermark.com Here's some life advice: Using the word "ideas" to refer to data collected about real-life makes you sound like you're trying pull some word BS. Implicating other people are being intellectually lazy when you haven't bothered to double check you read their post correctly is not going to make them think you're acting in good faith. Especially if you then go to bat for Google, because dear lord do you have to be out of the loop to not have noticed Google is going through platform decay.
-
@mark@mastodon.fixermark.com 2025-06-25 14:14
@Asimech@mastodon.social If they're directly copying OSM, why is there a multi-month gap between editing OSM and fixing the map? With that much gap, the explanation could also have been Google cleared the backlog of help reports and finally collected new ground-truth in the area using their own vehicles.
-
@mark@mastodon.fixermark.com 2025-06-25 14:20
@Asimech@mastodon.social Believe me, as a former Googler, I have all kinds of opinions about their platform decay. ... I also had a front row seat to how the sauce is made for years, so when people throw around words like "stealing" when nobody took issue with search engines scraping the web to build search indexes for decades my hackles raise. We have copyright law because people disagree, deeply, on the ethics of intellectual property protection. Even Jefferson was suspicious of the value of patents while supporting them: "...but generally speaking, other nations have thought that these monopolies produce more embarrasment than advantage to society..." Me personally, I come at it from the question of societal benefit, and I think it's best if all our maps are as correct as they can be, in every source. And if it can be proved that Google directly appropriated OSM data in violation of copyright law, they should be sued and the copyright owners compensated.