Elektrine lite

← Feed

@superketchup@social.vivaldi.net

2026-05-24 10:28 UTC

@kapis@social.anartist.org @hrefna@hachyderm.io @kallekn@mastodonsweden.se not any. there are 2000 native speakers. children from esperanto families with first language Esperanto. https://youtu.be/A9BO3Sv1MEE?si=II9oyFsd6w9SfjQs

Replies (2)

  • @kallekn@mastodonsweden.se 2026-05-24 12:39

    @superketchup@social.vivaldi.net @kapis@social.anartist.org @hrefna@hachyderm.io They are all bilingual or trilingual, they have all attended school in some other language, so Esperanto is not their primary language. And I do not think there are 2000 native speakers alive now, if there ever gave been. Possibly 200. By the way, I'm the editor of the Esperanto news site https://www.liberafolio.org/

    Open ##3030735

  • @hrefna@hachyderm.io 2026-05-24 18:34

    @superketchup@social.vivaldi.net The question being _primary_ language matters here. Sure, I'm sure there are some, though I am dubious on the sources there, even let's grant for the sake of argument 2000 (there were around 1000 native speakers in 2022 the world according to Ethnologue, and I'm wildly suspect of the claims that go into the millions of those with secondary learned language fluency, but we'll grant even that). 1. That's still not those who use it as a primary language. The language is also overwhelmingly spoken in a small number of northern european countries by dominant groups, it doesn't have the same ethnographic, political, or representative power of even a language like Ainu, which is endangered and has 15 native speakers. 2. That primary language number is not in the context of a west coast urgent care center asking about primary language. 3. That's basically completely missing the point I was making. Like to an extraordinary degree. Going "well actually" on the number of Esperanto speakers, given that the list also includes Elamite. Which hasn't had a native speaker in probably 2000+ years. @kapis@social.anartist.org @kallekn@mastodonsweden.se

    Open ##3030739