Elektrine lite

← Feed

@emilymbender@dair-community.social

2026-02-21 16:45 UTC

Doctorow could have gone into these details; could have said something about the particular LLM he chose was built (whose data, trained how, how much data, what kind of further data work in RLHF); could have drawn a distinction about use cases. >>

Replies (4)

  • But instead he wrote a defensive screed, seemingly imagining someone knowing about his LLM use ascribing to him all of the ills of everyone's LLM production and use. A missed opportunity, to be sure.

    Open ##2329375

  • @jmcclure@sciences.social 2026-02-21 19:55

    @emilymbender@dair-community.social This distinction about use cases is the important point in my view. So much so that I wasn't fully on board with the first paragraphs of the Smashing Frames article (though I loved the rest). For example, the analogy to wanting to be vegan but accepting vegetarian. I am convinced of the value of reducing our meat consumption and animal farming. But personally I don't find eating meat morally objectionable on principle. If I did, I'd *not* make exceptions. >>

    Open ##2329395

  • @m@martinh.net 2026-02-22 01:10

    @emilymbender@dair-community.social Hi from a random Internet person! I wondered if you have a view on "Sovereign" models like Apertus? Per https://raw.githubusercontent.com/swiss-ai/apertus-tech-report/main/Apertus_Tech_Report.pdf FWIW I am a genAI septic who started out feeling quite positive about this development, but then cooled on it rapidly once I realised that it doesn't address a) environmental impacts, or b) potential harms when genAI is used naively - or for plausible deniability by people doing bad stuff ¯\(ツ)/¯ For anyone reading this who hasn't come across Apertus before, there are now several models like this with characteristics such as: Full disclosure of training datarobots.txt is respected during scrapingTraining corpus includes under-represented languages/culturesMeasures taken to mitigate harm are documentedCode base is open source, not just the weights

    Open ##2329400

  • @dalias@hachyderm.io 2026-02-23 10:31

    @emilymbender@dair-community.social That would have required admitting/exposing that the thing he used was unethically trained and violating the consent of the people whose works were used in making it. So of course he didn't do it.

    Open ##2329401