Elektrine lite

← Feed

@mattblaze@federate.social

2026-09-26 17:26 UTC

@gooba42@mastodon.social well, I’m an engineer and I don’t think “going rogue” is a useful term either colloquially or technically here. It’s buggy software. Or maybe not buggy, but intentionally malicious. But either way, software lacks the agency required to up and decide to “go rogue” on its own. It does what the software is programmed to do.

Replies (2)

  • @datarama@hachyderm.io 2026-09-26 17:33

    @mattblaze@federate.social @gooba42@mastodon.social I think "going rogue" is a bad term because it diffuses responsibility. Compare: "OpenAI's AI went rogue and meddled with US government websites" vs. "OpenAI meddled with US government websites". "but the agent did it" is precisely as bad an excuse as "but my computer did it", just with more steps.

    Open ##4859763

  • @dominykas@fosstodon.org 2026-09-26 18:01

    @mattblaze@federate.social @gooba42@mastodon.social I'm not sure "programmed" conveys the entirety of how LLM based agentic systems are built. They can go beyond what they were told to do. It's more like "they will do whatever is necessary to fulfill the task, unless explicitly programmed (sic) not to (and might not follow all the rules even then)". This does not absolve the engineers, the enablers of responsibility. Just that the emergent behaviors exist and are broader than "programmed software".

    Open ##4860252