Elektrine lite

← Feed

@jcoglan@mastodon.social

2026-07-24 16:32 UTC

"the tech would be reasonable and useful if there weren't a perverse investor bubble around it" is nonsense. the bubble is a product of what the tech explicitly aims to achieve, and the tech exists *because* investors are willing to fund it to fulfil those aims. you can't separate these things

Replies (2)

  • @jcoglan@mastodon.social 2026-07-24 16:34

    investors aren't pumping money into b/c they're wildly irrational and deluded about its capabilities or profitability. they're funding it because eliminating jobs and destroying epistemic reality are useful outcomes to them, and the tech *is* doing those things

    Open ##4518904

  • I can only sort of square that circle, and more as an academic excersize than me genuinely agreeing with him, I am going to try. I think he is looking at the technology sans politics (problematic) and arguing that after the VC funding dries up and these models become open source (second problematic assumption) that the rest of us can then just run them on a spare GPU since there will be a glut of them on the market (third problematic assumption). The first problematic assumption is that any technology can be separated from the political environment that birthed it. These LLMs in.particular came to prominence when tech workers began to get uppity and talk about unions and shit and was explicitly marketed as a labor replacement. The second assumption is that these bleeding edge models ever become open source/open weight, which assumes that Altman and cohort's raging narcissism causes them to open weight the models in the interest of public good, instead of keeping the models closed and lobbying the govt to start a protectionist racket, locking in a captive audience. The third problematic assumption is GPUs dropping in price because the investment dries up. This only happens if the whole thing goes belly up so spectacularly that there is a global recession with the whole shindig. I think Doctorow is looking at that last possibility as the starting point for his thesis and that seems like it is starting from a position of maximalist harm and working then towards a utopia. Works for science fiction, problematic here in the Real. My post makes it seem like I dislike Doctorow and the opposite is true - I am glad he speaks up about antitrust enforcement as the policy lever to give workers more power. I just think his reasoning here is flawed (similar as @jcoglan@mastodon.social here)

    Open ##4518906