Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Asimech@mastodon.social

2025-06-23 05:05 UTC

@mark@mastodon.fixermark.com And I'm having a hard time accepting a moral framework built on "ends justify the means if I invent a narrative where the means were noble, instead of what most people's experience indicates". They couldn't be bothered to check themselves, so they scraped data. Then they could've at least given credit. But couldn't do even that. And here you are, glazing them for it.

Replies (2)

  • @Asimech@mastodon.social 2025-06-23 06:41

    @mark@mastodon.fixermark.com Something occurred to me: You claimed Google was cross-checking. But the source for both data was the same person. It was the equivalent of a journalist being told a thing by "Alice", dismissing it and months later reading the Wikipedia page edited by "Alice" and then reporting it as true. Well, maybe Google did some other checking. But because they don't attribute, but just claim all map data under their own license, we can't check their work. But "all's well that ends well" eh?

    Open ##5024172

  • @mark@mastodon.fixermark.com 2025-06-23 12:47

    @Asimech@mastodon.social We don't actually know that they scraped osm and repeated it verbatim. Another hypothesis is that they cross-check against osm, and use discrepancies between their data and osm as signal to go collect more data. And another valid hypothesis is coincidence, in the story above, there was months of time between the osm change and the Google maps update. Maybe they used OSM. Maybe one of their other data sources got updated. Maybe one of their other data sources is scraping OSM and they don't know it. Since they are ultimately responsible for the content of the map, there is non-zero risk in trusting OSM verbatim because anybody can edit it. I highly doubt they are relying on it as an unverified data source.

    Open ##5024180