2026-11-03 19:46 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@exasperation@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2026-11-03 20:10
I just read the underlying survey results from the linked source in the footnotes. Which are from a 2020 study, not a 2010 study, but I’ll leave it to someone else to fix the Wikipedia page, as my VPN address is blocked from editing Wikipedia. 22% of instructors teach systematic phonics as their method of instruction. 4% use whole language, the system that discourages phonics emphasis. 68% use balanced literacy. And of those, when asked to give their own written definition, more than half (52%) explicitly mention phonics as part of it, literally the plurality answer in what the phrase “balanced literacy” means. 21% mention “phonemic awareness.” 14% mention “all five essential components of reading instruction,” which comes from a National Reading Panel definition that includes phonics and phonemic awareness as 2 of the 5. The study report itself explicitly disclaims trying to draw too strong of a conclusion that teachers aren’t using phonics just because they didn’t use the word in their definition. And other keywords like “whole language” only got 6%. But we don’t need to try to infer what percentage, because the study itself explicitly surveyed the importance of phonics. For the question “When you’re teaching students to read, how much emphasis do you place on phonics?,” 70% answered “a lot,” 28% answered “some,” 2% answered “a little,” and 0% answered “none.” The study itself pretty strongly supports the idea that almost everyone in the US is teaching phonics as the foundation of reading for 5-7 year olds.