Elektrine lite

← Feed

@tao@mathstodon.xyz

2026-06-02 14:38 UTC

I am very impressed by the final product, which has been refined extensively over the last few months, and endorse it wholeheartedly. Many of the points made in the declaration have also been made elsewhere -- my own writings and talks often touch on some subset of these, for instance -- but having them all assembled coherently in one document adds significant additional value. I urge everyone in the field to read the declaration, and consider signing it (I myself have already signed). All the recommendations in the declaration are excellent, but I will highlight "Participate in public discourse". Perhaps notoriously, practicing mathematicians have a tendency to focus more on technical mathematical tasks, such as solving open problems, than on communicating the purposes of such technical work to the broader public. So long as we had a near-monopoly on the ability to accomplish these tasks, we could have this luxury of only discussing "safe" technical topics in public; but in the new era of "proof abundance", it is increasingly important that we also debate the "soft" aspects of our field, such as our goals and values. See also the previous announcement https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24914 by Commelin et al. of the Leiden declaration from March of this year. (2/2) EDIT: See also the New York Times article https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/02/science/ai-mathematics-leiden-declaration.html

Replies (2)

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz I have a PhD in Pure Maths, but haven't been involved in research for 35 years now. Is there value in me signing this?

    Open ##5128394

  • @wikiemol@mathstodon.xyz 2026-06-03 00:19

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz This is the kind of thing that gives me a lot of hope for the future! It is very difficult for people like myself, who have few explicit connections, to see the intentions of prominent mathematicians who are currently shaping our future. I think this lack of insight contributes to a lot of anxiety from the public. Even before the AI boom, this has been a huge problem. I am elated to see an explicit call for transparency and open discussion of values (this is something I know you have promoted for most of your career, and I have always been extremely grateful for this). I am certain that this declaration will ease a lot of the anxiety students such as myself are feeling! That said, one of my remaining worries for the future is the vagueness of 'understanding, clarity, and judgment' (mentioned in the declaration). This seems like a hole that can be co-opted by various interests. It seems to me that there is a large amount of variance on this topic even among mathematicians on classical topics. With such huge incentives currently present to get AI to demonstrate true 'understanding', I am very worried our definition of 'understanding' will get co-opted by commercial interests, or else that we will continuously be accused of 'moving the goalpost' as AI continues to progress. To be honest, I think this should be a top priority. I think this topic is necessarily philosophical to an extent, and thus 'softer' than what most mathematicians think about in the 21st century, but is absolutely essential in order for true meaningful action to take place. I also do not think it is as intractable as it might at first appear.

    Open ##5128397