Elektrine lite

← Feed

@CosmicTurtle0@lemmy.dbzer0.com

2026-11-09 19:34 UTC

The main reason is that you don’t know what rights you might be giving up in the future. There was controversy when v3 was released that it closed the loop hole for companies to technically be in compliance of GPL but locked people out by using encryption keys. FOSS people, of course, said this was needed due to companies like TiVo at the time using hardware keys to prevent people from boot loading their own firmware when they were using Linux. Torvalds supported the version but did not want to relicense Linux to force companies to stop the practice. And look were we are now: tivoisation is everywhere from Pixel to routers to tractors. Your point that FSF is likely to make improvements of the license is valid, but you always want to make sure that you agree with the new license. They could, in future versions, say that by using the license, you transfer your rights to FSF. Better to be explicit with the version you agree with and then relicense if needed.

Replies (1)

  • @trevor@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2026-11-09 19:59

    I don’t see what rights were given up when protecting against tivoisation though? I don’t think companies should have the right to exploit people’s labor in the first place, especially if they lock-down whatever work they derive from it. I think Linux should be (A)GPLv3 and Linus is usually very wrong about many things. But I see your point if you want to be explicit and careful about the future. But given the track record of GPL license improvements, I’m inclined to think that the “or later” suffix is actually a good move, particularly if your project has multiple contributors and you don’t to worry about asking permission later to relicense to whatever improved GPL may exist in the future.

    Open ##5510824