2026-09-05 20:02 UTC
One of the great weakness of "Western" intellectual culture and especially that part of Western intelligentsia which is chiefly concerned with popularizing intellectual concepts, i.e. presenting simplified summaries of difficult intellectual concepts to general audiences, is that it's developed no clear sense of how to respond to the durability and invincible appeal of the irrational.
The "rationalists" have a peculiarly unearned faith in persuasion. They're not good at debating but they have a tremendous attachment to the idea that "Socratic" discourse, asking questions that slowly elicit some abstract conclusion, is the way to find out The Truth, none better.
(cont'd)
Replies (1)
-
@mxchara@cyberpunk.lol 2026-09-05 20:05
They forget something important about all those Platonic dialogues: they're scripted. Plato isn't giving an eyewitness account and he takes care to sidestep his own presence in the conversations he's purporting to relate as the deeds of his friend Socrates. Really he's writing embellished and slightly fictionalized scenarios about idealized characters designed to be the vectors for chosen viewpoints. There's nothing wrong with this exactly, but it's susceptible (in basically the same way as the Bible) to misinterpretation along the lines of a false "literalism", i.e. acting as if Plato is giving us verbatim the words spoken in "real life" by Socrates. (etc.)