Elektrine lite

← Feed

@exasperation@lemmy.dbzer0.com

2026-11-03 21:18 UTC

No, I’m saying that what you’re talking about doesn’t actually link cause and effect. Curriculum selection is a small part of the educational challenges in this country (and in other countries), and many students come up short for all sorts of different reasons, from family/home issues, nutrition, poverty, truancy and attendance, instructional quality (regardless of what written curriculum the instructor should be teaching), etc. Meanwhile, some excellent students can thrive no matter what they’re given. It’s not like the kids attending the whole language schools grew up with like 0% literacy rates. So there are kids that were gonna learn to read well under either paradigm. And some that were gonna be bad readers under either. To pin the broad swath of reading issues on this narrow slice of curriculum design is overstating the effects of curriculum. That’s what my original comment was getting at, and still what I believe. More details about curricula don’t actually address my non-curriculum points: that you can’t just argue with an idiot on the internet and conclude that the reason for his idiocy is because he must’ve been taught with the three cueing method. That’s too much of an inferential leap.

Replies (1)

  • The idea that how you teach children something doesn’t affect how well they learn it is flat out stupid. Going ‘oh well some kids are better at learning this core skill than others so it doesn’t matter how you teach them, therefor it doesn’t matter how you teach anyone because some of them were just going to be bad at it no matter what’ is built on assumptions on top of assumptions. I don’t accept that some children are destined to be bad at reading, and I hope to god anyone teaching children doesn’t believe that. Even special ed teachers should be believing in the capabilities of their students. Literally everything you’re bringing up is addressed in the reporting I’ve linked you. You aren’t tellling me anything new. It doesn’t change that starting kids off on a poor foundation for understanding how to read is not going to magically turn them into readers. In fact, the very issues you bring up (wealth inequality) tie in to how this is disguised in rich peoples’ school districts by the fact that they can just afford tutors if their kid struggles. BTW, if you want people to focus on the non-curriculum aspects of teaching you should probably just say that instead of hinting around it and then implying someone is an idiot for not changing the subject.

    Open ##5507617