← Feed
@Vicinus@piefed.zip
2026-10-21 05:54 UTC
This sounds horrific to me! The question in my mind is not how many ghosts to allow over here, but how to generate authentic interactions between real humans. We don’t need every single niche covered, we just need people to enjoy their time spent here.
I do not want to have to scroll down reading through tens to hundreds to thousands of comments, none of which represent real humans who would respond if I replied to them - that is the precise opposite of what I want.
I do not think that the overall lack of content is the problem here - it’s the overall lack of content that is worthwhile to read, …
I didn’t think I conveyed the idea well. It would not be an automated or bot process (Reddit comments wouldn’t be added as Threadiverse comments). The good/useful comments from Reddit would be utilized by a poster to add to their own threadiverse post to help add more relevant content (Example that got 57 comments).
A further 90% improvement can be attained by blocking Lemmy.ml …
While that may be the fastest solution, the triad haven’t been doing great in at least the last few months, even without major intervention (Post with Data):
Lemmy.ml:
Difference from 3 Months ago: -103 MAU (-5.5%)
Difference from 1 week ago: -23 MAU (-1.3%)
Posts and Comments (per week): 727 (+106 vs historic)
hexbear.net:
Difference from 3 Months ago: -78 MAU (-5.7%)
Difference from 1 week ago: -18 MAU (-1.4%)
Posts and Comments (per week): 1659 (-3545 vs historic)
Lemmygrad.ml:
Difference from 3 Months ago: 22 MAU (+3.9%)
Difference from 1 week ago: 0 MAU (0%)
Posts and Comments (per week): 311 (-1 vs historic)
Average of the other 16 Instances (of Top 20, excludes lemmy.world who’s similarly crashing):
Difference from 3 Months ago: -16 MAU (-1.4%)
Difference from 1 week ago: +3 MAU (+0.3%)
Posts and Comments (per week): 387 (+22 vs historic)
It looks like hexbear.net is suffocating by itself. Maybe some users move from hexbear.net to lemmy.ml or the declining hexbear.net activity is forcing lemmy.ml users to be more active (I have no evidence of either, but for argument’s sake say they do), even then lemmy.ml is shrinking too.
In this very conversation thread there was a particular onerous troll who kept following our conversation and downvoting everything I said …
I did wonder what happened to that person.
New joiners, it seems obvious from the comments they leave (usually on other platforms after already leaving), don’t bother to put in the work to curate their experiences and instead simply flee …
Seems like some efforts toward better on-boarding could return good results (could include default blocks, etc.). I have some other analytics I need to get working again first, but after, I think I’ll take a stab at looking at decoupling and identifying key instance on-boarding differences that effect retention.
Edit: moved comma.
Edit 2: Looks like Pylova likes the subscribable block list idea: https://codeberg.org/quokkau/PyLova/issues/30
Replies (1)
-
Encouraging people to contribute only goes so far when this place is simultaneously discouraging people’s contributions. It is systemic, not limited to ML, and needs major efforts including enhanced technical capabilities to try to solve. Note that if ML ever were to be defederated, the absolute most toxic trolls would simply switch to using their alts on some other instance such as Lemmy.World, which they have announced they will do in advance, several years ago. They even indicated that they would make apps that automate the process of trying to send messages to someone, cycling through an array of alts until one is found that is not banned on that instance (or by that recipient?) - no truly does mean to simply push forward all the harder, for some.
But making a more firm stance would also send a signal about what is desired vs. not. Are calls for murder of all people in the Western World acceptable? Apparently, judging from their presence, yes.
Most places are defederated from HB - which was not always the case (I was on both StarTrek.Website and Discuss.Online prior to blocking them), but now that it is I don’t worry about them so much as ML that is still sending out content that turns people away.
I don’t know how to solve this problem, I only showed references in support of the fact that the problem lies there in front of us. Or at this point, behind us, since once a reputation is gained (for e.g. nostr, 4chan, etc.) it is exceedingly difficult to change.
On the whole, I think our reputation is closer to nostr and 4chan than it is to Bluesky. Institutionally at least, anything goes - including the worst CSAM. Something must be specifically blocked in order to filter it out (either that, or a new instance can include only trusted existing instances, but that runs into problems where new ones pop up all the time and will get excluded, so this approach seems not to be used by the vast majority of existing instances, at least the major ones).
I’ll take a stab at looking at decoupling and identifying key instance on-boarding differences that effect retention.
Wonderful!
Looks like Pylova likes the subscribable block list idea
That team is so energetic and helpful, it’s a pleasure to see it! 😁
Open ##5485934