2026-08-26 16:56 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@Photonic@lemmy.world 2026-08-26 17:50
I really don’t think you have any clue what you’re talking about. Do you even know where hydrogen comes from? It’s made from fossil fuels. And: As of 2023, less than 1% of dedicated hydrogen production is low-carbon, i.e. blue hydrogen, green hydrogen, and hydrogen produced from biomass. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production There is still at least a decade’s worth of research to be done and then you haven’t even built or produced anything. After that we need to build production facilities for hydrogen, as well as for massive structures for pressurized storage of hydrogen. We need to alter existing plants so they can burn hydrogen. You think any of that is going to be cheap? And it may not even work as well as people think. So yes, gas powered plants will be running for a long ass time in that scenario. In germany alone they recently discovered 43 millions tons of lithium. It’s not really a “rare” resource. It’s not really a “rare” resource. I used sodium-ion batteries as an example, since that is more widely available, but I can do the math with lithium-ion. Reactor-grade uranium: 3,456,000 MJ/kg Lithium ion batteries: 0.54 - 0.9 MJ/kg A lithium-ion battery consists of 7% lithium by weight. […] The battery’s composition also includes 7% cobalt, 4% nickel, 5% manganese, 10% copper, 15% aluminum, 16% graphite, and 36% other materials. thebatterytips.com/…/how-much-lithium-in-a-lithiu… So we do the math again: for the equivalent of energy in one kilogram of reactor grade uranium, you need (3,456,000 MJ * 1kg U) / (~0,7 MJ/kg * 0.07) = 345,600 kg of pure lithium So remember, that’s equivalent to one kg of uranium. Now one NPP can hold up to 100 tonnes of uranium fuel rods. So: 345,600 kg * 100,000 = 3,456e10 or ~34 billion kg …of lithium for one nuclear power plant. So if we add your mine in Germany to the equation: ~34 billion / 43 million = 800 times …the amount of lithium found in that mine to get the equivalent of energy that’s in a single nuclear power plant! 43 million may sound like a lot to a layperson, but it’s really not. And then we still haven’t touched the 7% cobalt, 4% nickel, 5% manganese, 10% copper, 15% aluminum, 16% graphite, and 36% other materials. …which are often harder to come by than lithium. if you need more energy you just quickly build more. Can’t say that about nuclear plants. What if you need more energy on quiet winter nights after overcast days? Battery prices get cheaper and cheaper every year. Production capacity is the issue. If we really want to go for worldwide storage, we can’t build anywhere near enough and they will get way more expensive really soon. Just remember what happened to memory prices recently… In that time renewables have evolved much more. Yeah no. Photovoltaic cells are nearing their peak efficiency. Meanwhile there is plenty of research going on about MSR’s and SMR’s that will increase nuclear efficiency and drive down the costs. Ya’ll can be fanboying/girling to Nuclear I actually did the math. Looks like you’re just “fan boying / girling” about non-existent storage tech, just winging it without putting any thought to it. Luckily for us, people at the top are doing their research a bit better than you did. France knows what’s up.