Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Jean_le_Flambeur@discuss.tchncs.de

2026-10-26 19:26 UTC

So reproducing racism is ok if someone else at a different time wrote the original? I honestly dont see your point. But dislike like ratio on my comment seems to indicate I am in a minority here

Replies (3)

  • @over_clox@lemmy.world 2026-10-26 19:51

    I was not one of the dislikes nor the likes on your comments, you are entitled to express your opinion and thoughts, and that’s okay with me. I do agree with you, it is a very derogatory and offensive word. But given the context and the timeframe the joke letter refers to, why bother censoring it out altogether? At least Lemmy caught and auto-censored the transcribed text I posted. Honestly, I scanned and OCR converted this probably like 20 years ago, and kinda blindly posted it from my old files after seeing the recent post about the 97 year old lady thankful for the transistor radio she was given. My bad that I forgot the original text contains such a derogatory word until after I posted it, otherwise I might have censored the word out in GIMP, but its posted now, and I don’t see any point in bothering to repost a censored version. Besides, at least to me, it would seem like listening to a bleeped out censored song, when you wanna hear the original lyrics, no matter how offensive. I do hope you have a good day, and hopefully aside from the bad word, I hope you otherwise got at least something of a laugh.

    Open ##5472658

  • @Hanrahan@lemmy.world 2026-10-27 09:01

    So reproducing racism is ok if someone else at a different time wrote the original? I’d suggest you don’t read Joseph Conrads eponymous book “Heart of Darkness” or a bunch of other books for that matter.

    Open ##5475754

  • @Feathercrown@lemmy.world 2026-10-27 09:21

    I think the disagreement is about whether presenting a work as-is is reproducing that work. I would say no-- unless you gain partial authorship by modifying it in a substantial manner, you are just presenting it. I think presenting works that contain views that we disagree with today can be (but is not always) okay. This gets pretty close to the line as it is being presented seemingly in line with its original intent as a joke and not as a form of commentary (I see why you might call that “reproducing” it). Overall it does not bother me since I have a fairly high tolerance for historical nastiness being presented rather than removed.

    Open ##5476135