Elektrine lite

← Feed

@gerenuk@mathstodon.xyz

2026-08-04 15:20 UTC

@tao@mathstodon.xyz I'm not a mathematician at all, but purely based on human values this feels quite "one-sided". It devalues the work of people who had great ideas and managed to create a correct result that other mathematicians have failed to produce (in whichever way). A result which is "merely correct", but not intuitive for the math community, may not be pleasant for most mathematicians, but it does not mean the author is a "bad parent" unless he obliges himself to add all bells and whistles that the majority of mathematicians would like to see. This presupposes the analogy to a child and derives nasty statements from that. Maybe a computer verified proof is a crop instead. And the farmer has no motivation and in particular no time to open a chain of restaurants all over the world to prepare nice dishes from it. There could be lots of hobbists having novel ideas - which the whole math community has missed - and which yield computer verified results. These hobbists may not have the time to follow up with the whole tail that traditional mathematicians would appreciate. This "first step results" could be appreciated for what they are and any professional mathematician may make the proof more intuitive. To my knowledge lots of complicating proofs have been considerably improved by others. As an outside person I rather find the protectionist witch hunt from mathematicians on AI results rather strange.

Replies (0)

No replies.