2026-09-24 19:26 UTC
@Bredroll@mas.to @tansy@wandering.shop I don't know specifically what algorithm the various "AI detectors" use but at best they're worthless in a week or two, like you said, and at worst they're literally trying to do something impossible. I have a suspicion that a lot of them boil down to utilizing an LLM on the text, in which case it's fundamentally nonsense regardless of what they do with the output.
If that were the case, it would be... say you take a survey of a classroom and get everyone's birthdays. You now have a distribution of birthdates for the class. You then ask someone for their birthday, then check if that birthday is within the distribution (it is, because you built it on the classroom). Then you accuse them of it not being their real birthday, but one they took from the distribution.
Do these "AI detectors" work like that? I don't know. But I don't trust them *not* to do something that statistically useless.
Replies (1)
-
@aud@spectre.asta.lgbt 2026-09-24 19:35
@Bredroll@mas.to @tansy@wandering.shop sorry, that was kind of a tangent, because their main actual purpose is to be a weapon against Black people and other groups that people want to eliminate (and not just from public life). I just suspect they have 0 theoretical grounding to stand on and kind of want that to be more widely discussed/talked about so that they can be rejected immediately out of hand when they come up, but it's obviously a bit tangential to the points being made here...