Elektrine lite

← Feed

@tao@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-03 15:39 UTC

Fundamentally, problems in pure mathematics, such as the global regularity problem, serve a different purpose than immediately practical problems, such as that of finding a cure to a specific disease, or increasing the energy efficiency of some engine. In most cases in pure mathematics, the problems are posed not because we desperately want the solution to these problems in and of themselves, but because we have seen from past experience that human-directed efforts to solve these problems tend to spur further development of the field through the efforts to solve such problems, and then to digest any partial or complete solutions that emerge for further insights. Prematurely solving the problem by purely AI-powered methods - particularly without full transparency into the solution process - can contaminate this process to the point where it actually becomes a net negative for the progress of mathematics as a whole. (6/6)

Replies (6)

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-05 15:19

    A clarification in response to recent rumors about a possible solution to the Navier-Stokes problem: I am not aware of any significant developments in this regard; the above discussion is hypothetical, but not completely implausible at the current level of development of AI technology. The point remains that there is a substantial opportunity cost in converting a historically productive and motivating problem (such as Navier-Stokes regularity) into a mere viral social media post advertising some benchmark progress, rather than actually advancing the field and developing the next generation of both problems to ask, and people to work on them.

    Open ##5417581

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz well, in view of your predilection for the Ansatz, Selber schuld, perhaps?

    Open ##5417590

  • @hvc@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-03 16:57

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz , I have enormous respect for this perspective, especially the idea that in pure mathematics the path toward a solution can be as valuable as the solution itself: failed attempts, partial insights, new techniques, and the understanding developed along the way. Still, I wonder whether the two paths must be in conflict. An AI-derived solution and a fully human, transparent, pedagogical development could coexist. They might advance mathematics in parallel: sometimes independently, sometimes overlapping, sometimes sharing ideas or intermediate results. An AI solution need not replace the human journey. Mathematicians could still reconstruct the argument, seek more natural proofs, develop intuition, and turn the result into genuine mathematical understanding. Knowing that something is true and understanding why it is true are not the same achievement... And there is, perhaps, a more romantic possibility: what could be more beautiful than a human mathematician and a machine independently arriving at the same key idea in some corner of a difficult problem? Such a convergence might itself reveal something profound about the structure of mathematics and the nature of reasoning. Perhaps the challenge is not to choose one path, but to preserve both.

    Open ##5417591

  • @mnl@hachyderm.io 2026-09-03 17:06

    @tao@mathstodon.xyz I think there are a lot of parallels to computer science, where one could consider the “daily bread programming”, ie “let’s hack our way through something that’s a reasonable enough solution to the problem” the equivalent of using computer assistance to get to the goal without using the occasion to discover and understand more fundamental principles. But, CS as a field that doesn’t try to directly solve say, a logistics backend for a small business (an incredibly rich problem that can barely be formalized), but can be used as guidance and feedback mechanism to work on more fundamental principles of computing. Or, the same way the steam engine predated thermodynamics as a field of study, llm created solutions could serve as guidance for the actual goal of creating/discovering human understandable descriptions of new structures. Sorry for the rambling, but I’ve very much switched my programming approach to “llm, make the thing I want to make, then figure out some of the fundamental abstraction behind it, and teach me, so that I can express myself more precisely and concisely for my next task”.

    Open ##5417593

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz I understood nothing of the mathematics of your example, and understood everything about the problem you have presented.

    Open ##5417624

  • @tao@mathstodon.xyz Maybe consider using an ActivityPub instance with an adequate message length limit instead of all those awkward splits?

    Open ##5417626