2026-11-03 15:18 UTC
Replies (1)
-
@luciferofastora@feddit.org 2026-11-04 15:30
I think the disdain is less for you specifically as for the initialism itself. If the point of all these various initialisms is to find a shorthand encompassing a certain family of marginalised groups, the “inclusive” version dilutes it. It’s similar to “not all men” and “all lives matter”: it doesn’t actually address the root issue, just soothe the feelings of people more concerned with how they’re perceived than how the actual victims of the given problem feel. Besides, being an ally should just be a normal thing for decent people, not worth special recognition. When trans-* people can get safe, effective and affordable gender-affirming care without having a dozen doctors ask several times each whether they’re really, really, really sure (and also without worrying about getting hate-crime’d), a lesbian couple in a video game no longer sparks a shitstorm, aces get a “skip sex scenes” option for popular shows and pronouns aren’t anything special any more, then we can wonder whether allies should be included. But by then, I’m not sure there’s much of a point any more: what would you even ally against? If you want a term that includes allies, how about “anti-bigotry alliance”?